What God Allows: The Crisis of Faith and Conscience in One Catholic Church

What God Allows: The Crisis of Faith and Conscience in One Catholic ChurchBy Ivor Shapiro.  Doubleday, New York, 1996.

This intimate work of literary journalism follows a year in the life of a Western New York Catholic church. The Toronto Star‘s book columnist, Philip Marchand, described it as “…a narrative, written in a dispassionate, scrupulously factual and at times dryly humorous tone, that conveys, for all its low-key style, some compelling human drama. Shapiro starts with a certain disadvantage in this respect. There is no villain in the piece, no stark contrast between pleasant and obnoxious individuals. Everyone in this book is trying to become a better human being.

“What God Allows has much of the impact of good realistic fiction, with revealing dialogue, a carefully observed setting, and searching portrayals of human personality. … Some of the conflicts between these individuals seem astonishingly trivial… but most of the conflicts are rooted in deeper controversies that have wracked the church since Vatican II…. ”\

More Reviews

Excerpt